Comedy /

Score: 59%( 407 votes )

Overview: An adopted girl discovers her talent for butter carving and finds herself pitted against an ambitious local woman in their Iowa town's annual contest.

Cast:

Jennifer Garner
Laura Pickler

Yara Shahidi
Destiny

Hugh Jackman
Boyd Bolton

Ty Burrell
Bob Pickler

Olivia Wilde
Brooke Swinkowski

Alicia Silverstone
Julie Emmet

Rob Corddry
Ethan Emmet

Ashley Greene
Kaitlen Pickler

Pruitt Taylor Vince
Ned Eaten

Kristen Schaal
Carol-Ann Stevenson

Phyllis Smith
Nancy

Garrett Schenck
Orval Flanagan

Judy Leavell
Helen Flanagan

Joe Chrest
Butter Fan

Deana Ricks
Butter Fan's Wife

Kelly Tippens
Mrs. Moore

Dodie Brown
June Carmichael

Brett Hill
Hayden

Mark Oliver
Martin Caswell

Cindy Creekmore
Danielle Mattingly

Jeanne Evans
Mrs. Gunderson

Corena Chase
Mrs. Schram

Jason Yudoff
Announcer

Andy Daly
Radio Announcer (voice)

Heather Cates
Laura's Fan (uncredited)

Gavin Casalegno
Art Class Student (uncredited)

Christine Scheller
Transitional Home Worker

Michael C. 'Mike' Allen
Corporate Employee

Jennifer Benton
Car Buyer

Charlotte Biggs
State Fair Patron

Gavin Casalegno
Art Class Student

Pearce Chadwick
Webelo

Ted Ferguson
The Minister

Keri Shahidi
Biological Mother