Mystery / Thriller / Romance /

Score: 60%( 930 votes )

Overview: Newly-discovered facts, court records and speculation are used to elaborate the true love story and murder mystery of the most notorious unsolved murder case in New York history.

Cast:

Ryan Gosling
David Marks

Kirsten Dunst
Katie Marks

Frank Langella
Sanford Marks

Lily Rabe
Deborah Lehrman

Philip Baker Hall
Malvern Bump

Michael Esper
Daniel Marks

Diane Venora
Janice Rizzo

Nick Offerman
Jim McCarthy

Kristen Wiig
Lauren Fleck

Stephen Kunken
Todd Fleck

John Cullum
Richard Panatierre

Maggie Kiley
Mary McCarthy

Liz Stauber
Sharon McCarthy

Marion McCorry
Ann McCarthy

Mia Dillon
Katie's Aunt

Tom Kemp
Katie's Uncle

Trini Alvarado
Sarah Davis

Tom Riis Farrell
Barry Davis

Bruce Norris
Brian Callender

Francie Swift
Kelly Callender

David Margulies
Mayor

Glenn Fleshler
Sidney Greenhaus

Stephen Singer
Solly Sachs

Francis Guinan
Daniel Patrick Moynihan

Ellen Sexton
Moynihan's Wife

William Jackson Harper
Moynihan's Assistant

Ashlie Atkinson
Bonnie Felder

Donna Bullock
Divorce Attorney

Pamala Tyson
Lula Baxter

Julie Moran
Julie Moran

Diane Kagan
Scream Therapist

Socorro Santiago
Nurse

Barbara Ann Davison
Woman at Baby Shower

Zabryna Guevara
Waitress

Lanny Flaherty
Rooming House Landlord

Robert Clohessy
Building Superintendent

Lázaro Pérez
Building Elevator Operator

Michelle Hurst
Newscaster

Craig Walker
Assistant District Attorney

Lola Pashalinski
Woman at Luxor

Jerry Grayson
Man at Luxor

Tony Torn
Theater Manager

Zoe Lister-Jones
Press Conference Reporter

Tristan Comeau
Young David

Amelia Martin
David's Mother

Matthew Floyd Miller
Young Sanford

Peter Becerra
Officer at Search

Mary A. Kelly
Vermont Realtor

Jeong Kim
Waiter at Disco

Andy Tsay
Waiter

Ruel Jusi
Butler

Arwen
Ivan the Dog